“Einstein was mistaken!” After discovering a black hole, scientists ask for a new theory of relativity
Get link
Facebook
X
Pinterest
Email
Other Apps
The general theory of relativity was published by the physics genius more than a century ago, to refine Isaac Newton’s law of universal gravitation. Providing a unified description of gravity as a geometric property of space and time, or spacetime, this model is still currently used by scientists as an explanation of gravitation in modern physics.
Einstein’s theory has important astrophysical implications as it alludes to the existence of black holes – cosmic phenomenons in which space and time are distorted in such a way that nothing, not even light, can escape.
At the center of a black hole, as described by general relativity, may lie a gravitational singularity, a region where the spacetime curvature becomes infinite.
But while mathematics says a singularity is possible, nature apparently proves these do not exist, Discovery Channel’s ‘How The Universe Works’ exposed.
The series explained: “When a giant dying star collapses, the mass of the star falls in and keeps falling in crushing down into an infinitely small point.
“This is called the singularity.”
But physicist Max Tegmark believes the “singularity” is “just a fancy way of saying ‘we have no idea what is happening here’.”
Astronomer Phil Plait explained why some experts have an issue with using this theory.
He said: “The way our physics describes black holes when they form is you’re taking a finite amount of mass and you’re collapsing it down.
“Its volume should shrink all the way down to zero, but that means it has infinite density and infinite gravity.
“That doesn’t make sense.”
Theoretical physics Lawrence Krauss then explained why some are questioning Einstein’s theory.
He added: “If you make a prediction and the answer is infinite, then it tells you that there is something wrong with your prediction.
“We have never seen infinity in the universe.
“Maybe a black hole with an event horizon described by general relativity just isn’t the proper description of the physics.”
Quantum mechanics is a fundamental theory in physics that provides a description of the physical properties of nature at the scale of atoms and subatomic particles.
Leading astronomer and assistant director for Science Communication at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Centre, Michelle Thaller, explained why it is key to the debate.
She said in 2018: “Have you ever thought about the term quantum mechanics and what those terms actually mean?
“Everything in the universe is broken up into tiny units and there is a basic unit of energy, time and space that cannot be divided any smaller.
“There is a limit to how small those things can be.”
The smallest unit in the universe is what is known as a Planck Length to physicists.
But if there is a universal limit on the smallest size, then something infinitely small cannot exist, according to some scientists.
Quantum mechanics expert Sean Carroll explained: “If infinity doesn’t exist, then singularities don’t exist.
“And if singularities don’t exist, then Einstein’s theory of General Relativity is not correct.
“The simplest thing we can do is change some equations, change his theory of gravity.
“Let’s invent what we would call exotic speculative physics.”
This has led scientists to invent the theory of the Planck Star.
Passing one in space would look like a black hole, but without a point of singularity at its core.
The star is just like a black hole, but it obeys the rules of quantum mechanics.
Physicist Max Tegmark detailed the new theory that has been proposed.
He said: “Maybe things can be collapsed down to less than the Planck Length, or maybe you get stuck with a Planck-sized nugget.
“The reason why there are so many alternatives to black holes is because you can write down a gazillion different postulated mysterious new kinds of matter and say ‘this exists, so maybe that explains the data’.
“The problem is there is no evidence that any of that kind of stuff exists.”
The 2023 MotoGP season proved to be one of the most com Pet itive campaigns for the series, as the championship battle between Ducati duo Francesco Bagnaia and Jorge Martin raged until the final race of an historic campaign that also saw sprints introduced for the first time. Bagnaia ultimately won out by 39 points to score his second championship, capping off a banner year for Ducati in which it won a record 17 GPs across six of its eight rider s, achieved 43 total podiums and eight rostrum lockouts. There were standout performances elsewhere, with Aprilia winning twice with Aleix Espargaro and Honda scoring a sole victory in a miserable campaign courtesy of Alex Rins. New winners emerged too, while others put in commendable performances without ever getting to the top step of the podium. To decide who we consider the 10 best rider of the 2023 MotoGP season , we’ve taken results into account but also results relative to machinery at their disposal. A...
Quick facts When is it? Every November 13th Tagged as People & Relationships What's the hashtag? #WorldKindnessDay Have we missed something? Kindness Day was born when a collection of humanitarian groups came together on November 13, 1997, and made a “Declaration of Kindness”. Likewise, on Kindness Day everyone is encouraged to make a similar declaration. Donating books, food, or clothes to your local community is a great way to celebrate. However, pledging to commit just one act of kindness is no less worthwhile: hold the door open for a stranger, compliment your neighbor on their collection of garden gnomes, let your partner have control of the TV remote for the evening. History of World Kindness Day World Kindness Day first began as a day of observation by the World Kindness Movement. The organization was registered as an official NGO under Swiss law in 2019. However, the History of the group reaches right back to a Tokyo-based convention in 1997. A r...
The Mavericks are going backward after a hot start to the season, dropping three of their last four as they head off to a mini two-game road trip on the West Coast. That will begin with a tough test against the red-hot Lakers, who have now won six of seven and shored things up on the defensive end. Will L.A. succumb to fatigue on the second night of a back-to-back, or does it have enough firepower to win this heavily-anticipated matchup? Let's break down the NBA odds and dive right into it with our free NBA picks and predictions for Mavericks vs. Lakers on Wednesday, November 22. Mavericks vs Lakers odds Mavericks vs Lakers predictions I wrote yesterday when discussing the Los Angeles Lakers that it should just be a matter of days before they’ve risen into the Top 10 in defensive efficiency with the recent progress they’ve made on that end, and lo and behold they enter play on Wednesday ranked 10th in the NBA when it comes to points allowed per 100 possessions....
Comments
Post a Comment